Roth IRA vs. HSA: Which One Should You Prioritize?

May 16, 2021

In this highlight, we give our thoughts on one of the all-time great debates: should you prioritize your Roth IRA or HSA?


Uh, you want to fight over one? Oh, goodness, I thought that last one would be one we’d fight. No, this was one we’re gonna fight on. All right, this is what Alex said: Roth IRA or HSA. I can only fund one. He or she already knew where you were going. Which should I fund first and why? I’m 30 with a wife and I have three kids, so medical expenses are a sure thing in the future, but wanted your opinion.

Oh man, this one is… It’s less of a fight in me trying to balance my desire to minimize taxes in the current versus minimize taxes in the long term because of the value of compounding growth. Um, oh man, because I still want to say both. Just do both, you know, go figure out a way to do both, but no. I mean, but it is… I think that so I’ll answer it in this way.

Is that you know, look, we know 96% of people who use health savings accounts use them as annual clearing accounts meaning that you put the money in, you get the current year tax deduction, you pull the money out, and you actually use it to pay your medical expenses. That’s novel, that’s good. And if you’re tight on money, I think that’s understandable. There is a bonus level status if you can actually invest the HSA money to let it grow, but with somebody with three children in the house that’s too hard to do. So that current year tax deduction, so I’m actually talking myself into a different answer here is because I think somebody with three children and you can’t afford to do both, your money is tight. I mean, you’re probably thinking, what, how do I prioritize the money? You’re probably not in a high tax bracket at that point. If money is tight, that means you’re not in a high tax bracket. So if that’s the case, I’m back to feeling like that Roth might be because the money of what it could become later is so much more valuable as taxes go up. You know, is the government spending more money that could come into play, but since there’s probably not a great current year tax benefit to either the HSA or the Roth on what you’re having to pay your taxes currently, so because there’s no tax deduction, you’re looking at me like I have three eyes and you’re gonna have a different opinion.

I will see your answer and I’ll raise you a slightly different answer because you said one of the things you love is a tax regrowth. Well, I’d argue inside of an HSA, you get that same thing. So you also get a current year tax deduction. So that’s to me, that’s where it gets edged out, right? That’s where it gets edged out because if I put the money in the HSA, I get my tax deduction now, well, I can invest those dollars and they can grow and grow and grow and grow all the way to retirement, and if I have medical expenses then or if I’ve been tracking my medical expense, I can pull it out tax-free. So I get to treat it the exact same as I get to treat the Roth IRA with the caveat it has to be for medical expenses, but I did get a benefit on the front end, so for me, the HSA edges it out.

Now, Brian, you said something interesting, but you’re probably in the 10 to 12 tax bracket at that point. Well, 10 to 12 percent of tax savings is better than zero tax savings. Fight me on that. That’s 100, right? But here’s the same thing, you just say that I think is a little financial mutant hack. And I want to think through this, but I think this would work. You said, “Hey, if you got three kids, there’s a chance you’re kind of having to use that as an entry your slush fund anyways. If you’re gonna do this and you’re someone who has at least $5,000 of medical expenses every year anyways, one thing I might do is I might put the money in and then reimburse myself. And then, if I have something left over, then I’m going to go max out the Roth.” So, that was kind of, I get it, you brought it full circle. That’s what I still was going to close it out and say, “At the end of the day, I want them doing both. I want you to figure out what you can squeeze in lifestyle or side hustling. If you could do it, and I love what you just did. You brought it full circle. Go take the current year tax deduction, use it as a clearing account, but then figure out a way that that reimbursement from your health savings account is funding your Roth IRA. Man, that’s good stuff. That’s good. I like that. I like that we did that live on camera. I was super nervous that wasn’t going to work well.”




Most Recent Episodes

Financial Advisors React to Money Advice from ChatGPT

Will ChatGPT be your new financial advisor? In this react episode, we’ll break down some money advice from ChatGPT and compare it to our own thoughts and opinions. Enjoy the Show? Sign up for the Financial Order of Operation (FOO) Online Course! Sign up for our Know...

Financial Planning 101 (By Age) 2023 Edition

Throughout every decade, there are different areas of your financial life that come in and out of focus. In this episode, we'll discuss what you need to focus on by age, pitfalls to watch out for, and how to know you're doing it right. In this episode, you'll learn:...

Is the 2023 Housing Crash Around the Corner?

Housing prices skyrocketed after the pandemic to all-time highs, and mortgage rates have more than doubled since 2020. Homes are harder to purchase for more Americans, which means it’s more important than ever to make sure you are ready to buy before purchasing. In...

Watch This Before Rebalancing Your Investment Portfolio!

85% of Americans don’t rebalance their 401(k). Are they making a huge mistake? In this episode, we’ll discuss the “why” behind rebalancing, how to do it, and the data on whether or not rebalancing can increase your return. In this episode, you’ll learn: What...

Don’t Make This HUGE 401(k) Mistake!

Americans are making a HUGE mistake in their 401(k) that could cost them thousands by retirement. We’ll talk about why this is happening and how you can avoid making the same mistake in this Q&A episode! For more information on how to make the most out of every...

Alex Hormozi’s Top Money Advice! (Financial Advisors React)

In this episode, we react to Alex Hormozi's financial advice. Enjoy the Show? Sign up for the Financial Order of Operation (FOO) Online Course! Sign up for our Know Your Number Course! Check out our Net Worth Tool! Get FREE downloads full of financial advice from...

Everything You Need to Know About Finances in Your 20s

In this episode, we discuss everything you need to know about finances in your twenties. In this episode, you’ll learn: The top financial advice for your twenties How to start building wealth and the steps you should take Enjoy the Show? Sign up for the Financial...

The Most Valuable Asset in Building Wealth!

This episode will show you how to maximize the most valuable resource you have - starting right at this moment. What is it, you may ask? It’s TIME. If you give your money time to grow, you’ll be amazed at how much your dollars can become - it’s incredible! How wild is...